The Fall Economic Statement: Positively Uncertain

The Canada’s 2024 Fall Economic Statement (FES) could not have arrived at a more turbulent political juncture. The resignation of the Deputy Prime Minister and growing discontent with Prime Minister Trudeau’s leadership have destabilized the government. The resulting uncertainty clouds the legislative agenda, threatening to derail critical economic reforms. For the Canadian Lenders Association (CLA) and its members, this instability represents a double-edged sword: while it may disrupt progress on crucial files, it also opens opportunities to influence the regulatory dialogue.

Dominic LeBlanc’s appointment as Finance Minister introduces an additional element of unpredictability. Known for his relational and consensus-driven leadership, LeBlanc’s approach could accelerate legislative processes. However, a lack of detail-oriented policymaking may result in challenges during implementation. The CLA is committed to engaging with the new minister to ensure that industry concerns are adequately addressed.

Through this lens, here is a run down of the FES:

Balancing Interest Rate Caps and Non-Prime Lending

The CLA’s advocacy has borne fruit in ensuring a clear distinction between payday lenders and responsible non-prime lenders. The FES rightly targets exploitative payday lending practices, including prohibiting the bundling of credit insurance products. However, the broader non-prime market has been spared from onerous regulations that could have curtailed access to credit for millions of Canadians. This nuanced approach aligns with the CLA’s push for targeted regulation.

Nevertheless, the fight is far from over. The CLA continues to oppose the inclusion of insurance charges in APR calculations under the Criminal Code. Such a move risks reducing access to essential financial products and undermining consumer protection. Optional insurance products offer a vital safety net for borrowers facing unexpected life events. Overregulation in this area would drive borrowers toward unregulated markets, with dire consequences for financial stability.

Clamping Down on Predatory Debt Advisors

The government’s crackdown on unlicensed debt advisors is a welcome development. The FES proposes hefty penalties for non-compliance with the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) and introduces civil remedies for restitution. These measures promise to protect consumers from deceptive practices while reinforcing trust in legitimate financial advice. The CLA has consistently highlighted the harm caused by such predatory actors. While the proposed reforms are encouraging, their success will hinge on robust enforcement mechanisms and timely implementation.

Open Banking: A Path to Innovation

The FES reaffirms the government’s commitment to open banking, with a targeted launch date of early 2026. This framework, supported by a $44.3 million investment in the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, aims to modernize Canada’s financial ecosystem. Key provisions, such as the prohibition of screen scraping and the establishment of a uniform accreditation system, promise to enhance security and foster innovation.

For CLA members, the benefits are clear: open banking will unlock new fintech opportunities, drive competition, and improve access to financial services. However, the multi-layered governance structure—involving federal and provincial oversight—must avoid fragmentation. A harmonized approach will be essential to ensure the framework’s success.

Mortgage Stress Test Reforms: Progress with Caveats

The removal of the stress test at renewal for uninsured mortgage holders is a step forward in promoting competition. Borrowers can now switch federally regulated lenders without requalifying, provided loan terms remain unchanged. Yet, the exclusion of provincially regulated institutions creates an uneven playing field, limiting borrower choice and undermining competition.

The CLA urges the government to adopt a harmonized approach that includes all lending institutions, federally and provincially regulated alike. By addressing these gaps, the government can foster a truly competitive mortgage market that benefits all Canadians.

Strengthening AML/ATF Measures

Efforts to bolster Canada’s anti-money laundering and anti-terrorist financing (AML/ATF) regime align with the CLA’s recommendations. Proposed definitions for reporting entities—focusing on significant players in the financing and leasing sectors—strike a balance between mitigating risk and minimizing compliance burdens for smaller operators. The CLA will continue to engage with policymakers to ensure these measures are effective and proportionate.

SR&ED Tax Incentives: Catalyzing Innovation

The enhanced SR&ED program, with increased expenditure limits and broadened eligibility criteria, is a boon for Canada’s financial sector. These updates provide critical support for innovation, enabling lenders to invest in cutting-edge technologies and compliance systems. The CLA encourages its members to leverage these incentives to drive growth and strengthen their competitive positioning.

The 2024 Fall Economic Statement offers a mixed bag for Canada’s financial sector. While reforms in open banking, mortgage competition, and SR&ED tax incentives signal progress, political instability casts a long shadow over their implementation. The CLA remains steadfast in its advocacy for a balanced regulatory environment that supports innovation, competition, and financial integrity. By working collaboratively with policymakers, the CLA aims to safeguard the interests of its members and the millions of Canadians who depend on equitable access to credit.

Here is a full review of the FES in our pressroom: https://www.canadianlenders.org/press/cla-review-of-the-2024-fall-economic-statement/

Sign up for our 2025 Summit Series