A Very British Scandal: The Hidden Costs of Car Loans

Here is a summary of a FT.com article on the scandal around inflated dealership commissions in the UK by Martin Arnold and Alistair Gray. See full article 

Abstract: The UK car finance industry is grappling with a major scandal following a Court of Appeal ruling that hidden commissions paid to car dealerships by lenders were unlawful if not fully disclosed to buyers. The case, sparked by complaints from consumers, could cost banks up to £44 billion in compensation and threatens the viability of commission-dependent dealerships. The ruling exposes systemic practices where dealerships inflated loan interest rates to increase commissions, often without buyers’ informed consent. This has raised questions about the fairness and transparency of the sector, prompted regulatory scrutiny, and sparked fears of tighter credit availability. The Supreme Court is set to review the judgment in April, potentially leading to widespread redress for millions of car buyers over the past two decades.

A recent ruling by the UK Court of Appeal has thrown the car finance industry into turmoil, exposing systemic issues that could cost banks billions of pounds and reshape the availability of consumer credit. At the heart of the scandal are hidden commissions paid by lenders to car dealerships, inflating costs for buyers without their informed consent.

The Landmark Case

The case that brought this issue to light involved Marcus Johnson, a factory supervisor from Wales, who unknowingly paid a £1,650 commission—nearly 25% of the car’s price—on a loan to finance his 2017 car purchase. The court ruled that dealerships have a fiduciary duty to act in their customers’ interests when arranging financing. The decision, which also involved two other cases, has far-reaching implications for the consumer finance sector.

The Ripple Effects

Banks face a compensation bill that analysts estimate could reach up to £44 billion, rivaling the infamous payment protection insurance (PPI) scandal. Financial institutions, including Lloyds Banking Group and Barclays, have begun setting aside provisions for potential payouts. The Finance & Leasing Association warns that the ruling could restrict access to credit, especially for low-income consumers, and disrupt the viability of car dealerships, many of which rely on commission-based financing to survive.

A History of Hidden Costs

The UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) found in a 2017 review that discretionary commissions allowed dealerships to raise interest rates on loans, leading to an estimated £300 million in excess annual costs for consumers. In response, the FCA banned such commissions starting in 2021. Despite this, the recent legal decisions suggest that even flat-rate commissions, if not properly disclosed, may also be deemed unlawful.

Legal and Financial Uncertainty

The Supreme Court is set to review the judgment in April. If upheld, millions of car buyers over the past two decades could seek compensation for hidden commissions and inflated interest costs. However, the process of unwinding these agreements, known as “rescission,” raises complex questions about calculating damages, particularly when cars have been sold or loans repaid.

Industry Reactions and Future Implications

Dealerships argue that the ruling jeopardizes their business model, with some smaller banks and lenders also facing significant risks to profitability. The FCA is considering an industry-wide redress scheme, while many lenders have revised their policies to ensure greater transparency. However, dealerships report that the changes have had little impact on consumer behavior, as most buyers prioritize monthly payment amounts over commission details.

A Broader Consumer Finance Issue

The case has prompted scrutiny of other sectors where commissions play a role, including loans for household goods and insurance products. Consumer advocates warn that the controversy could harm the UK’s reputation among international investors and lead to higher costs and reduced availability of credit for consumers.

As the legal battles continue, the car finance scandal highlights the need for greater transparency and accountability in consumer lending. The eventual outcome will likely shape the future of financial regulation and consumer protection in the UK.

Sign up for our 2025 Summit Series